I was given a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Devil’s Playground is an action-packed novel centred around Mia Sawan, American-Lebanese spy for mysterious company The Firm. A Christian banker is crucified in Beirut, then the 10-year old daughter of a powerful mayor in Azerbaijan is kidnapped. Both crime scenes have tags linked to a known criminal, but Mia isn’t so sure it is an open-shut case – or of what the link between the two actually is.
The idea for this novel is incredibly strong. This has been well thought out, researched and it is clear that the author knows his stuff. The start of the novel, for example, is shocking and incredibly powerful. Mia’s character is a strong willed, intelligent, sex positive woman of colour and I wish we could see more of these, especially coming from white male writers like Kidson.
I love the concept, and was looking forward to reading the book. Unfortunately for me the writing didn’t quite match the strength of the ideas. The text tells an awful lot, and is very open – considering this is a book about covert investigation, this isn’t the best match. It is difficult to find a good balance between getting your intentions across and over-explaining, and in Devil’s Playground this hasn’t been perfected. I also found that while some things were over-explained, such as what Mia wore, others weren’t discussed enough. I would have liked to have seen more of “The Firm”, and some more scenic description – it may not be as exciting as the action packed scenes we saw so much of, but I believe it would’ve added more depth and realism to the book. It is set somewhere that for many Western readers is a mystery, so it would’ve been nice to have had a better picture painted of the settings. It may be that I don’t read action often, but I find that scene after scene of action gets tiring rather than having the desired effect. When every page is written to shock or excite I find that I desensitise and lose interest. Of course there are rest breaks, but the text is very fast paced.
Overall, the novel had a controversial but gripping plotline, however I felt that this was let down by poor editing and a mismatched writing style. This is very easy to do and I admire the clear amount of knowledge and thought put into the concept, but the writing distracted from the story too much for me to fully enjoy it.
See you soon,
Last Post: Review Wednesday | Book Review – The Amber Shadows
2 thoughts on “Review Wednesday | Book Review – Devil’s Playground”
All “action writers”—and film-makers—could benefit from this review. Action alone adds up to nothing. In most of the books in her “Miles Vorkosigan” series, semi-SF writer Lois McMaster Bujold does a brilliant job of creating and populating a world in which the action, when she unleashes it, really does matter. Sorry to sound off, but the Devil’s Playground review struck a chord and struck it hard.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t read that series but it sounds great and I think saying that the action “matters” speaks volumes – it’s not that action is bad but too much just wears on the reader and lacks the significance that would really grip the audience, and I think that was my issue with Devil’s Playground.